profile

Josh Knox

Just Joshin' #99 (Humor)

Published about 1 month ago • 3 min read


1 Family Photo:
Humor

Why did Joshua have no parents?
Because he was the son of Nun.

This joke is not funny.

Its premise describes some sad orphan situation. Its punchline relies on bible trivia.

It was also my favorite joke when I was 6. This is worse when I think about confused strangers assuming the setup was autobiographical.

I'm lucky we didn't send kids to therapy back then.

It reminds me of another piece of poorly constructed humor. In Albert Brooks' Looking for Comedy in the Muslim World, for reasons contrived by the plot, Brooks' character runs around India repeating a line and seeing who laughs:

Why is there no Halloween in India?
Because they took away the Gandhi.

Nobody laughs. As Roger Ebert pointed out in his 2006 movie review, "anyone young enough to find the joke funny...wouldn't know who Gandhi was." And vice-versa.

--

Humor's subjective, but some jokes are still better than others. There's good humor and bad humor too.

At its best, humor brings us together. We smile through shared context - a gif is funny because it reminds us of a movie scene we both like, a comic's observation unites us in noticing some everyday life absurdity.

The laughter identifies we're all in the same tribe.

Not all humor is like that though. Put-down humor says, "I am in my tribe because you are not. I am better than you." Sarcasm says, "I am better than everything," Not all funny is the same. Laughter for the sake of laughter is empty.

I'm not sure how to guide Calvin and Lawrence's sense of humor. How is one's sensibility here even formed?

I want to guard them from jokes at other's expense. I want to shield them from the allure of sarcasm.

Maybe I can do that while they're still young, but for how long? I can't control everyone they're exposed to. How do you police other people's jokes? How do you ask those people to also be mindful of their humor?

Anyways, the history of abstinence-base education efficacy is somewhat problematic. I'll have to come up with a better approach.


1 Dad Joke:
Calvin Jokes

Sid the Science Kid is Calvin's favorite TV show. It has a clear format: Sid wakes up, he has breakfast with his parents, he goes to school, he finds his friends, he learns something, he goes home. There's a part at the end where Sid and his friends gather to tell jokes about whatever the episode's theme happens to be.

Calvin like retelling Sid’s jokes. Sometimes he mixes them up and accidentally creates anti-jokes, which I sometimes find more funny than the originals.

Guess which joke below is from Sid the Kid, and which one is Calvin's version:


Highlights:
Funny Thoughts

On Sarcasm by Andrew Bosworth

At first being sarcastic was incredibly satisfying. Whereas previously I might have made an earnest argument or asked a question, I now seemed to be able to jump right to the part where the group appreciated me and my contribution. What is even more impressive is it required very little thought to execute. I could often get a positive reaction even on topics I knew almost nothing about.

It was when I noticed this last point that I decided that sarcasm was not for me. Sarcasm “works” because it alludes to a critique without ever actually making it.

Sarcasm does nothing to advance our understanding of the world around us or help us improve it.
Sarcasm is too lazy to engage in such important discussion. Sarcasm attacks without providing solutions. Sarcasm implies alignment where there is none. Sarcasm can rally a mob without providing any recourse to disarming it. Sarcasm is magnitude without direction.
At the time I loved The Daily Show with Jon Stewart but in retrospect I fear it created a generation of people who can make jokes about the status quo but feel powerless to improve it.
So if you want to make a critique then do it explicitly and earnestly. Take a position of your own and defend it. It takes a lot more work but in exchange it holds the promise to create a great deal more value for society.

Podcasts

Working It Out and Good One are high quality podcasts on the art/craft of jokes/comedy/standup. Give them a try, if that’s a thing you’re into:

Working it Out - Mike Birbiglia

Suggestions: (Ira Glass), (Jim Gaffigan), (Gary Gulman)

Good One - Jesse David Fox

Suggestions: (Nate Bargatze), (Cristela Alonzo), (Gary Gulman)


iamJoshKnox Highlight:

Words that Matter:

A few weeks ago, I posted a collection of essays that matter to me.

The awesome people at Matter republished my post in their newsletter!


Also, my book is still available on Amazon here or reply to this email and it would be a pleasure to gift you a copy.


Fancy a Chat?

Grab some time on my calendar to share a funny story from this week:

Let's Chat!

Book some time even if you don't know what you want to talk about:
https://calendly.com/iamjoshknox

Until next week,
iamJoshKnox​


Thoughts? Feedback?
😊Hit Reply and let me know😊


Josh Knox

Hi! I am Josh Knox. Read more of me here: 👇

Read more from Josh Knox

1 Family Photo: Water Cycle The Discovery is a science museum in Reno. We celebrated Lawrence's birthday with a visit. The museum's biggest exhibit is a model of the Truckee River watershed and the water cycle, complete with "clouds" cut from stacks of pringles-shaped platforms towering 3-stories above the atrium. The clouds create an irregular jungle gym for "climbers of all ages". Lawrence loved the clouds—undeterred by their height—dragging me up and down the tiny crawlspaces they created....

1 day ago • 3 min read

1 Family Photo: Raccoon! We had a cabin visitor this week. A raccoon popped over and looked in on us. He didn't just pass by—he stopped, pulled on the sliding glass door to check if it would budge, peeped through to see what was happening inside. It felt like a zoo exhibit, but in reverse. I could hear the raccoon thinking: "LOOK AT THE ADORABLE HOOMANS! HOW SAD THEY'RE TRAPPED IN GLASS BOX. DON'T THEY WANT TO EXPLORE OUTSIDE?" The raccoon started at us. We stared at him. He wouldn't leave us...

8 days ago • 7 min read

1 Family Photo: Screens This week, we only stopped once on our seven-hour drive to Truckee. In travel-dad golf, that's shooting birdie on a par 3. [*insert joke about drivers*] The boys passed some of the time looking at their books, drawing on little pads, singing songs, and napping. Mostly though, they just gazed out their windows, occasionally asking questions about things we passed. I don't know if it makes any difference to life-outcomes (and I don't judge anyone else's parenting...

15 days ago • 4 min read
Share this post